Tue February 7, 2012
Flipping 'The Bird' Just Isn't Obscene Anymore, Law Professor Argues
(Note: This is a post about obscenity. Proceed with caution if the subject bothers you.)
We've got one more thing to say about "the bird" and singer M.I.A.'s flipping of her middle finger on national TV during Sunday's halftime show at the Super Bowl.
"Is it inappropriate? That's another question," he tells NPR's Audie Cornish. But, he says, "it doesn't mean what it used to mean."
"In the time of Caligula ... it was intended to be representative of a phallic symbol. Not today."
Instead, Robbins argues, flipping the bird is an expression of "frustration or rage or anger or protest or disdain."
And in fact, he says, it's now "part of the mainstream of American culture."
It would appear that many Two-Way readers agree, at least judging from the question we first posted yesterday (it's still "open" if you want to express your opinion):
Much more from Audie's conversation with the professor will be on the show. Click here to find an NPR station that broadcasts or streams All Things Considered. We'll add the as-aired interview to the top of this post later.
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.
AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:
And I'm Audie Cornish. NBC and the NFL had to issue apologies this week over the Super Bowl halftime show. British singer, M.I.A., made an obscene gesture during her performance with Madonna, flipping her middle finger to a Super Bowl audience of 114 million.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
CORNISH: Pop stars seem especially fond of the gesture. Famous finger flippers include everyone from country star Johnny Cash to pop starlet Lady Gaga.
Ira Robbins, law professor at American University, knows the history of this particular insult well. He joins us now to talk about it. Hello there, Ira Robbins.
IRA ROBBINS: Hi, Audie.
CORNISH: So, to start, where does this gesture come from? And how far back in history do we have to go to find people taking offense to it?
ROBBINS: If you go back in recorded history, it's about 2,500 years, although there are apocryphal stories that it goes back even further. The Greek playwright, Aristophanes, refers to the middle finger in his play, "The Clouds," basically treating it as a phallic symbol.
We see this in Roman literature, as well, and Roman history. In fact, the use of the middle finger was so prevalent in those times that they gave it a special name. They called it the digitus impudicus, meaning the impudent finger.
CORNISH: Can you describe, maybe, what the most famous incident of its use has been?
ROBBINS: There is no one most famous use. It's a prevalent gesture. We've seen it not only from entertainers this week and recent months and years, but two years ago, Senator Jim Bunning, a U.S. senator, used the finger toward a journalist when they got into some sort of verbal altercation.
You led into this story referring to this as an obscene gesture. I would have to argue that it's not obscene at all, that it's part of the mainstream in American culture.
CORNISH: And there have been a lot of legal cases over the years, I gather, about the middle finger and I don't know if it's ever really been considered illegal or worth suing over.
ROBBINS: It is considered illegal in many jurisdictions, but there is a case from Oregon in 2010 in which a regular guy thought that he had an absolute First Amendment right to give the finger to police officers whenever he saw them. Not just if he was being ticketed. Dozens, sometimes hundreds of times a day, whenever he would pass a police officer, he would give the finger.
And they brought him to court on this on disorderly conduct charges. He ultimately won. He settled for $1,000, but in other jurisdictions in which the application of the disorderly conduct statute has been tested, there have been settlements for as high as $50,000.
CORNISH: Ira, is there anything that surprised about the way people reacted to this latest incident with the middle finger?
ROBBINS: I was surprised at how many reporters and the NFL itself have referred to this as an obscene gesture, something that was risque and inappropriate and I'd have to say I don't see it as obscene. I didn't see it as risque. Maybe the dancing during the halftime show was risque, but I don't see the use of the finger as that. Now, is it appropriate for parents to have their children see this during prime time? Arguably not, but that's a very different issue from the constitutional right to use the gesture.
CORNISH: Ira Robbins, professor of law and justice at American University, thanks so much for talking with us.
ROBBINS: Thanks for having me. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.