Politics
3:38 pm
Mon July 7, 2014

In Maine, A Gay Candidate With An Uneven Record On LGBT Rights

Originally published on Mon July 7, 2014 6:56 pm

Maine was among the first states to legalize same-sex marriage at the ballot box — and now, LGBT groups are hoping voters there will break new ground by electing the nation's first openly gay governor in November.

But Democratic candidate Mike Michaud only recently came out, and he hasn't always been a gay-rights supporter.

Responding to what he called a "whisper campaign" about his sexual orientation, the six-term congressman did something dramatic last November: He outed himself in a series of newspaper op-eds.

"Yes, I am gay, but you know, so what?" he told the Maine Public Broadcasting Network later that month. "You know, I am who I am."

That "who" is someone who punched a time clock at Great Northern Paper for nearly three decades; Michaud is one of only a few union-card-carrying members of Congress. Around northern Maine, he's known simply as "Mike."

Emery Deabay, president of the United Steelworkers Local 1188, said he doesn't think Michaud's coming out makes a difference to people who know him.

"Mike is Mike," Deabay said. "He went to Washington. You know he fought these unfair trade deals. He fought for veterans. That's what he does; everybody knows that."

Since going to Congress, Michaud has lined up with the left on social issues like abortion and gay rights. But his independent opponent, Eliot Cutler, says that was not the case when Michaud served for years in the Maine Legislature and voted against legislation to extend civil rights protections to gays and lesbians 19 times.

"You know, I don't care what your sexual preference is and I don't care whether you're out or not," Cutler said. "That was a moment, those were 19 moments, when principle was important and he voted no."

An attorney and entrepreneur, Cutler previously ran for governor in 2010 and supported same-sex marriage even before Maine voters legalized it in a 2012 statewide referendum. Over the past several decades, he and his wife have raised and spent thousands of dollars on LGBT causes.

It was Michaud, however, who was recently invited to serve as a grand marshal of the gay pride parade in Portland. And although Cutler also made an appearance at that event, he remains deeply hurt that Maine's largest gay-rights organization endorsed Michaud instead of him.

"It pained me ... because I had been committed to these issues for as long as I can remember in my life" Cutler said. "And to lose the endorsement to someone who hadn't, just because he is a) a Democrat and b) gay."

But Michaud says that Cutler, unlike himself, has never had to answer to constituents.

"My question is: Where were they when we were dealing with these bills in the Legislature? Where were they when we were dealing with them in Congress? I haven't seen Eliot do anything other than write checks," Michaud said.

Even as a gay man, Michaud says, his own position on LGBT issues has evolved over time, the same way it has for many voters.

Polls show him locked in a tight race with Republican Gov. Paul LePage, a favorite of the Tea Party crowd, while Cutler trails a distant third. But any votes Cutler picks off could swing the election.

Mark Brewer, a political science professor at the University of Maine, says Michaud's coming out could help him with progressive voters in southern Maine. But in his conservative home district, Brewer says, it could hurt.

"It's a more rural population. It's an older population," Brewer said. "It's a less educated population and all of those characteristics tend to correlate with being less supportive of same-sex marriage and other equality issues for homosexuals."

National LGBT organizations are throwing their financial support behind Michaud, whom they see as a role model for their movement.

And that's something that will continue to gnaw at Cutler, who says he is proud of the fact that when it comes to matters of equality, he's never had to evolve.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel. Maine was among the first states to legalize same-sex marriage at the ballot box. And now, two years later, LGBT groups are hoping that voters there will break new ground by electing the nation's first openly gay governor. As Maine Public Radio's Susan Sharon reports, the Democratic candidate only recently came out and hasn't always been a supporter of gay rights.

SUSAN SHARON: Responding to what he said was a whisper campaign about his sexual orientation, Democratic six-term congressman Mike Michaud did something dramatic; he outed himself in a series of newspaper op-eds last November.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

CONGRESSMAN MIKE MICHAUD: Yes, I am gay. But, you know, so what? You know, I am who I am.

SHARON: Who Michaud is, is someone who punched a time clock at Great Northern Paper for nearly three decades. He's one of only a few union card-carrying members of Congress, and around northern Maine, he's known simply as Mike. Emery Deabay, president of the United Steelworkers Local 1188, says he doesn't think Michaud's coming out makes a difference to people who know him.

EMERY DEABAY: Mike's Mike. He went to Washington, you know, he fought these unfair trade deals. He fought for veterans. That's what he does. Everybody knows that.

SHARON: Since going to Congress, Michaud has lined up with the left on social issues like abortion and gay rights. But Michaud's independent opponent, Eliot Cutler, says that was not the case when Michaud served for years in the Maine legislature and voted against legislation to extend civil rights protections to gays and lesbians 19 times.

ELIOT CUTLER: You know, I don't care what your sexual preferences is, and I don't care whether you're out or not. That was a moment - those were 19 moments, when principle was important, and he voted no.

SHARON: An attorney and entrepreneur, Cutler previously ran for governor in 2010 and supported same-sex marriage even before Maine voters legalized it in a statewide referendum. Over the past several decades, he and his wife have raised and spent thousands of dollars on LGBT causes.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED ANNOUNCER: And give it up for Mike Michaud, the first openly gay candidate to run for governor.

SHARON: Michaud was recently invited to serve as a grand marshal of the Gay Pride Parade in Portland. Cutler also made an appearance, but he remains deeply hurt that Maine's largest gay-rights organization endorsed Michaud instead of him.

CUTLER: It pained me, because I had been committed to these issues for as long as I can remember in my life and to lose the endorsement to someone who hadn't, just because he is, A, a Democrat and, B, gay.

SHARON: Unlike himself, Michaud says Cutler has never had to answer to constituents.

MICHAUD: My question is, where were they when we are dealing with these bills in the legislature? Where were they when we were dealing with them in Congress? I haven't seen Eliot out there other than writing checks.

SHARON: Even as a gay man, Michaud says his own position on LGBT issues has evolved over time, the same way it has for many voters. Polls show him locked in a tight race with Republican Governor Paul LePage, a favorite of the Tea Party crowd. Cutler trails a distant third. But any votes Cutler picks off could swing the election. Mark Brewer, a political science professor at the University of Maine, says Michaud's coming out could help him with progressive voters in Southern Maine. But in his conservative home district, Brewer says it could hurt.

MARK BREWER: It's a more rural population. It's an older population. It's a less educated population. And all of those characteristics tend to correlate with being less supportive of same-sex marriage and other equality issues for homosexuals.

SHARON: National LGBT organizations are throwing their financial support behind Michaud whom they see as a role model for their moment. And that's something that will continue to gnaw at Cutler, who says he's proud of the fact that when it comes to matters of equality, he's never had to evolve. For NPR News, I'm Susan Sharon. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.