NPR Cities: Urban Life In The 21st Century
4:36 pm
Tue September 11, 2012

Racial, Regional Divide Still Haunt Detroit's Progress

Originally published on Tue September 11, 2012 9:20 pm

For many years — perhaps even decades — Detroit has been the poster child for economic malaise. Adjusting for inflation, per capita income in metro Detroit dropped more than 20 percent between 1999 and 2010.

Some analysts say regional cooperation might have helped keep Detroit above water when the car industry sank, but that entrenched divisions that pit the city against its suburbs, and blacks against whites, have hindered that.

A Deeply Entrenched Regional Divide

Jeff Horner is standing in a park bordered by a concrete wall in the city's Eight Mile Wyoming neighborhood. Horner, an urban planning lecturer at Wayne State University, says this wall is a very visible marker of Detroit's segregated history.

In the 1940s, this part of Detroit was largely African-American, Horner says. In those days, the city was growing, and white residents sought to build houses next to black neighborhoods like this one. But first, developers needed to get financing — usually secured by the Federal Housing Administration.

"And the developer who wanted to develop in this area was told no by the FHA," Horner says. "Because it was considered to be too close to an African-American neighborhood. And so the solution that the developer came up with was to build a 6-foot-high wall that runs for about three long city blocks."

The wall is just one example of Detroit's historical divisions. In the 1950s and '60s, the car companies started moving factories from the urban core to the suburbs. Many white families followed, but discriminatory practices blocked that option for black families.

As a result, Detroit got poorer and blacker, while the suburbs got richer and whiter — especially after the city's 1967 riots over race and income disparities.

The wall where Horner stands is just a few blocks south of Eight Mile Road — still a stark dividing line. South of Eight Mile, the city of Detroit is still 83 percent black, with high levels of poverty. North of Eight Mile, Oakland County is 78 percent white and the richest county in the state.

But the demographics are shifting here, Horner says. Young white people are moving into the city of Detroit, while the racial makeup of the suburbs is changing.

"I would venture to say by 2020, there will be more black folks in Detroit suburbs than there are in the city of Detroit," he says. "We're on that path right now to have more suburban blacks in Detroit than in the city."

But in many ways, the acrimony remains, and it's tangible any time there's a debate over regional cooperation between Detroit and its suburbs. Inside the city, residents fear a loss of political power. In the suburbs, the fear is that hard-earned tax dollars will be siphoned off by a poorly run city.

It's a debate that's played out repeatedly through the years: over the city-owned water system that serves the suburbs, for example, and over the zoo and the convention center that serve the region but needed help staying afloat.

A City Gem Roils Tensions

The latest flash point is the city's 1,000-acre park, Belle Isle.

Local residents Thomas Short and Ruth Roman sit side by side in lawn chairs at the park, watching the freighters go by. They visit Belle Isle several times a week, and they're not happy about a proposal that would fold this park into Michigan's state park system.

"I would prefer it to stay in Detroit, the ownership of it," Roman says. "It's one of the jewels of the city. It belongs to the city."

The proposal is part of a consent agreement between the state and the city intended to keep Detroit from sliding into bankruptcy. But it's been derided by some — like Roman — as yet another attempt by people outside Detroit to erode the city's self-determination.

But the park is in need of work the city can't afford to do, says City Councilman James Tate. The park's once grand and exclusive boat club is now rundown, and Mother Nature is taking over the now-closed zoo.

Tate is part of a new contingent of people younger than 40 on the City Council. Born after the riots, they have a different take on regional politics from some of their predecessors.

Tate says it's time to look at a regional solution to Belle Isle's problems.

"I'm one of those guys, you just want to see progress," he says. "And I think it's important to not just say no to everything [just] because it's uncomfortable, and it's different than what you've been doing in the past."

A deal that would have the city lease Belle Isle to the state appears to be close. That would require City Council approval — and that's not a sure thing. Councilman Kwame Kenyatta says the state should keep its hands off Belle Isle.

"I think that has always been the question" of regional cooperation, Kenyatta says. "Can we be partners without [the state] controlling the menu of what's going to be on the table?"

Kenyatta says if Coleman Young were still mayor here, he'd be putting up a fight. Young was Detroit's first black mayor and a hero to many black Detroiters. He left office almost 20 years ago, but his name is still regularly invoked in debates over money and political power.

Bob Berg, a partner with the Detroit public relations firm Berg Muirhead and Associates, has a different take. Berg was Young's press secretary, and he's not so sure Young would be opposed to a state partnership to spruce up Belle Isle. He says Young was seen as antagonistic, even hostile, by many whites — both in the city and in the suburbs.

"A lot of white people were very uncomfortable in a situation where they were no longer in control," Berg says. "It's amazing — he's been gone for 15 years, and people still feel passionately. They either love him or they hate him."

Before serving as Young's press secretary, Berg did the same job in the 1970s for Michigan's white former Gov. William Milliken. Young and Milliken had a warm relationship, and Milliken fought for state funds to help Detroit institutions, like the Detroit Institute of the Arts.

Suburbs Rally Behind An Urban Institution

Today, Berg points to recent successes in city-suburb cooperation. Last month, the majority of people in Detroit's suburbs voted to raise their taxes to keep the DIA afloat.

Berg, whose firm handled PR for the campaign, says the first people in line at the museum the day after the vote were a couple from the suburbs who had never visited the DIA before.

"We were laughing later that if we were going to try to hand-pick, PR-wise, the first group to come through, that's who you'd have picked," Berg says. "There they are, they're from Livonia ... which until the last census was the whitest city in America. Over 100,000 [people]."

Berg says the museum vote is a sign that people are starting to see Detroit and its suburbs as one entity — that will succeed or fail together.

Belle Isle remains the next test. Many Detroiters are still skeptical that the state will be a fair partner when it comes to co-managing the city gem. But a successful deal could mark the emergence of a metro Detroit where cooperation trumps dysfunction.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

I'm Audie Cornish.

And now, the NPR Cities Project.

(SOUNDBITE OF THEME)

CORNISH: We're turning to diversity and the economy, how race relations can factor in a city's financial health. Today, we head to Detroit, which has struggled with economic malaise and racial strife. Cooperation between Detroit and its suburbs might have helped keep the region afloat when the auto industry sank but intractable divisions mostly prevented that.

Now, Sarah Hulett, of Michigan Radio, reports on some glimmers of hope.

SARAH HULETT, BYLINE: So I'm on the city limits. I'm driving down Eight Mile Road, and I'm looking for Birwood Avenue. Here it is.

(SOUNDBITE OF A TURN SIGNAL)

HULETT: I met up with Jeff Horner. He's an urban planning lecturer at Wayne State University.

JEFF HORNER: How do you do?

HULETT: Hi, Jeff.

When I told him I wanted some insights into Detroit's racial divisions, Horner suggested we meet at a park that's bordered by a concrete wall.

HORNER: We're standing on the east side of the wall. And in the 1940s, this part of Detroit was largely African-American.

HULETT: In those days, Detroit's growth meant white homeowners started looking to build houses next to black neighborhoods like this one. But first, developers needed to get financing, usually secured by the Federal Housing Administration.

HORNER: And the developer who wanted to develop in this area was told no by the FHA, because it was considered to be too close to an African-American neighborhood. And so, the solution that the developer came up with was to build a six-foot-high wall that runs for about three long city blocks.

HULETT: And this wall is just one very visible example of Detroit's segregation. In the 1950s and '60s, the car companies started moving factories to the suburbs. Lots of white families followed. But discriminatory practices blocked that option for black families. Detroit got poorer and blacker, and the suburbs got richer and whiter, especially after riots over race and income disparities in 1967.

HORNER: The wall very much is a symbol.

HULETT: The spot where Horner and I are standing is just a few blocks south of Eight Mile Road, which is still a stark dividing line; south of Eight Mile, the city of Detroit is still 83 percent black and full of poverty, north of Eight Mile, Oakland County is 78 percent white and the richest county in the state.

But Horner says the demographics are shifting.

HORNER: I would venture to say by 2020 there will be more black folks in Detroit suburbs than there are in the city of Detroit. We're on that path right now to have more suburban blacks in Detroit than in the city.

HULETT: There are also young white people moving into the city. A decade ago, I was one of them. But in many ways the acrimony remains. You can feel it any time there's a debate over regional cooperation. Inside the city, the fear is the loss of political power. Outside the city, the fear is that hard-earned tax dollars will be siphoned off by a poorly run city.

It's a debate that's played out repeatedly - over the city-owned water system that serves the suburbs, over the zoo and the convention center that serve the region, but needed help staying afloat.

And here is the latest flashpoint: a thousand-acre park called Belle Isle.

(SOUNDBITE OF SEA GULLS)

HULETT: Do the two of you come out here often?

THOMAS SHORT: Often.

RUTH ROMAN: Yeah, at least three or four times a week.

HULETT: That's Detroiters Thomas Short and Ruth Roman, sitting side by side in lawn chairs watching the freighters go by. They're not happy about a proposal that would fold this park into Michigan's state park system.

ROMAN: I would prefer for it to stay in Detroit, the ownership of it.

HULETT: How come?

ROMAN: Because it's one of the jewels of the city, you know, it belongs to the city.

HULETT: The proposal is part of a consent agreement between the state and the city that's intended to keep Detroit from sliding into bankruptcy. But it's been derided by some, like Ruth Roman, as yet another attempt by people outside Detroit to erode the city's self-determination.

(SOUNDBITE OF A VEHICLE DOOR)

HULETT: But the park is in need of work that the city can't afford to do. City Councilman James Tate took me on a drive around Belle Isle.

JAMES TATE: This is certainly one area that needs to be updated.

HULETT: The park's once grand and exclusive boat club is now rundown and Mother Nature is taking over the now-closed zoo. Tate says it's time to look at a regional solution to Belle Isle's problems.

TATE: I'm one of those guys that - we just want to see progress. You know, and I think it's important to not just say no to everything because it's uncomfortable and it's different than what you've been doing in the past.

HULETT: Tate is part of a new, under-40 contingent on the city council. Born after the riots, they've got a different take on regional politics than some of their predecessors. A deal that would have the city lease Belle Isle to the state appears to be close; that would require city council approval and that's not a sure thing.

Councilman Kwame Kenyatta says the state should keep its hands off Belle Isle.

KWAME KENYATTA: Partnership doesn't necessarily have to mean control. And I think that has always been the question: Can we be partners without you controlling the menu of what's going to be on the table?

HULETT: Kenyatta says if Coleman Young were still mayor here, he'd be putting up a fight. Young was Detroit's first black mayor and a hero to many black Detroiters. He left office almost 20 years ago, but his name is still regularly invoked in debates over money and political power.

BOB BERG: My name is Bob Berg and I'm a partner with Berg Muirhead and Associates in Detroit.

HULETT: Bob Berg says he's not so sure Young would be opposed to a state partnership to spruce up Belle Isle. Berg was Young's press secretary. Now he runs a PR firm. He says Young was seen as antagonistic, even hostile by many whites - both in the city and the suburbs.

BERG: A lot of white people were very uncomfortable in a situation where they no longer were in control.

HULETT: They still talk about it. My white neighbors still talk about Coleman Young, in a not very favorable way.

BERG: Right, it's amazing. He has been gone 15 years and people still feel passionately. They either love him or they hate him.

HULETT: Before Berg served as Young's press secretary, he did the same job for Bill Milliken, Michigan's white Republican governor in the 1970s. Young and Milliken had a warm relationship. And Milliken fought for state funds to help Detroit institutions like the one we're sitting in.

BERG: Well, we're sitting in the Rivera Court at the DIA.

HULETT: That's the Detroit Institute of Arts. I met him here to talk about a recent success in city-suburb cooperation. Last month, the majority of people in Detroit's suburbs voted to raise their taxes to keep this city institution afloat. Berg's firm handled PR for the campaign. He says the day after the vote, the first people in line were a couple from the suburbs who had never visited the DIA before.

BERG: And we were laughing later that if we were going to try to hand-pick, PR-wise, the first group to come through, that's who you'd have picked. There they are. They're from Livonia.

HULETT: A white suburb.

BERG: A white suburb which, until the last census, was the whitest city in America over 100,000.

HULETT: Berg says the museum vote is a sign that people are starting to see Detroit and its suburbs as one entity that's going to succeed or fail together. Belle Isle is the next test. Many Detroiters are still skeptical that the state will be a fair partner when it comes to co-managing that city gem. But a successful deal could mark the emergence of a metro Detroit where cooperation trumps dysfunction.

At the Detroit Institute of Arts, I'm Sarah Hulett for the NPR Cities Project. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.